Minetest logo

IRC log for #minetest, 2023-05-05

| Channels | #minetest index | Today | | Google Search | Plaintext

All times shown according to UTC.

Time Nick Message
01:04 Trifton joined #minetest
01:06 smk joined #minetest
01:34 YuGiOhJCJ joined #minetest
02:10 Blockhead256[m] RhineDevil: That's a non-standard installation location as far as I know. So as others said, you would need to compile with -DRUN_IN_PLACE=TRUE instead. The standard per-user place where Minetest will look for files is ~/.minetest/
02:13 Blockhead256[m] invisiblocks from what I can see bears some similarity to maptools
02:14 Blockhead256[m] I don't think maptools has that nice stick to visualise things though
03:35 RhineDevil joined #minetest
04:00 MTDiscord joined #minetest
04:23 lemonzest joined #minetest
05:03 RhineDevil joined #minetest
05:08 calcul0n joined #minetest
06:13 lissobone joined #minetest
06:13 lissobone Uhm, guys?
06:13 lissobone I have got a few questions.
06:13 lissobone I decided to finally fix the 'goodtorch' mod so it becomes actually good.
06:14 lissobone The fix consists of making the flashlight not bug out when in confined spaces or near a ladder.
06:14 lissobone I did it, but I feel like the mod is now missing its simplicity and determinism.
06:14 MTDiscord <jordan4ibanez> Then undo your changes I suppose
06:15 lissobone No, they're good on their own, but they conflict with something inside of me.
06:15 MTDiscord <jordan4ibanez> I don't think anyone here can answer that question then
06:18 jordan4ibanez[m] Libera links the users directly to matrix?
07:16 tel1 joined #minetest
08:18 Markow joined #minetest
08:34 sys4 joined #minetest
08:37 MinetestBot [git] BuckarooBanzay -> minetest/serverlist: use `max_age` instead of `cache_timeout` (for flask > 2.0) 6fba704 https://github.com/minetest/serverlist/commit/6fba704bb087d9e0359373ea01d8f94bff036717 (2023-05-05T08:36:08Z)
08:43 TomTom_ joined #minetest
09:14 Lesha_Vel joined #minetest
09:42 lissobone Why does minetest.net state that Minetest is 'open source'?
09:46 lissobone At the same time, content.minetest.net uses the term 'free software' and the FSF's Free Software definition.
09:49 gemmaro joined #minetest
09:54 rubenwardy Minetest is both open source and free software
09:54 rubenwardy Free and open source
09:55 lissobone left #minetest
09:57 rubenwardy ContentDB used both the free software definition and the open source definition https://content.minetest.net/help/non_free/
09:58 MTDiscord <Flamore> free as in free beer and free as in freedom
09:59 rubenwardy Ah, the policy only links to the fsf
09:59 lissobone joined #minetest
10:47 greeter greetings all :-) i'm trying to start my own MT server. the one i just started up as TONS of jungle, to the exclusion of virtually all other biomes except ocean. is that a known issue with certain settings or do i just have an unlucky seed?
10:47 appguru joined #minetest
10:49 lissobone Tons of jungle?
10:49 lissobone What's your seed?
10:49 greeter i'm trying to find that out. how do i do that?
10:49 lissobone The ffew2gqyjhnh4tqеf one?
10:49 lissobone This creates lots of jungle.
10:49 lissobone It's the default one for me.
10:49 lissobone You can possibly set a spawn in a different part of the world.
10:50 lissobone Or maybe pass something else to the seed.
10:50 lissobone Come on, don't be shy, try some seeds out!
10:50 lissobone btw
10:50 lissobone greeter: i need your seed
10:50 greeter might be my mapgen too. maybe carpathian has a lot of jungle?
10:51 lissobone I believe that most mapgens have the same biomes.
10:51 lissobone Only v6 has biome-dependent terrain.
10:52 greeter ah so i might want to try that then
10:57 greeter tried a new seed. forgot to change the mapgen. while the jungle in the new seed is still huge, it isn't insurmountably huge, i think we can live with this :-)
11:13 calcul0n i noticed that extremes biomes tend to be much larger than others
11:13 calcul0n those which are very hot/cold or dry/wet
11:14 proller joined #minetest
11:14 calcul0n probably because biomes are defined with heat/humid range of 0..100 in mind while it's generally around -20/+120
11:55 appguru joined #minetest
12:20 Noisytoot joined #minetest
12:55 lemonzest joined #minetest
13:41 mrkubax10 joined #minetest
13:42 fluxionary joined #minetest
13:57 Helenah How do I tell Minetest to attempt re-loading surrounding chunks? I'm fed up of relogging now... :/
14:17 appguru joined #minetest
14:20 RhineDevil joined #minetest
14:21 RhineDevil Does someone have a cool seed with a mountain overlooking the sea facing the sunset or sunrise?
14:39 lissobone Not yet, at least, but I've got a very cool seed with a massive mountain somewhere in the world.
14:39 lissobone It's, like, 600 blocks tall.
14:56 lissobone Aye, any lua gurus here?
14:56 lissobone I'm trying to create a particle spawner that would create particles in a burst.
14:56 lissobone Basically, I am fixing the thruster mod.
14:57 lissobone Right now it has minetest.after() plus minetest.add_particle(), which creates a few particles over a course of, like, a second.
14:57 lissobone But it doesn't go well with the fact that the thruster gives instant velocity.
14:58 lissobone So far I managed to crash minetest with my attempts.  It returned an unknown error with no description.
15:03 MTDiscord <luatic> Why do you need a Lua guru?
15:04 MTDiscord <luatic> Sounds like just reading the API docs for minetest.add_particlespawner should suffice?
15:10 RhineDevil^ joined #minetest
15:19 definitelya joined #minetest
15:25 imi joined #minetest
15:30 Guest73 joined #minetest
15:34 Alias joined #minetest
15:35 Guest73 Hi everyone, ShadMOrdre here.  Wanted to share some mapgen seeds that I've explored over the years.  And I want to point out that you can enter a word, it does not have to be a numeric string.  So with that in mind, for a mountain overlooking the ocean for a sunrise/sunset, try the mapseed, "Fermat".  Other good seeds include, "Terraria",
15:35 Guest73 "Home", "Patience", "BonitaVista", "Cambraea", "ede", "Theia", and "TheIsleOfSodor".
15:37 Guest73 The "Fermat" seed works well with both v7 and Valleys.  Experimentation is always recommended!
15:38 Guest73 Ooops, map seed "Eden", in between "Cambraea" and "Theia".
15:41 Guest73 If you want to see a Sauron like tower at 0,0,0 (origin), use the map seed "PharrMana"  A 1km high "tower" mountain, like the tower that hosts the "Eye of Sauron"
15:44 Guest73 For the tower, use that seed, and use Carpathian.
15:45 Warr1024 joined #minetest
15:48 Guest73 Could someone help me understand what this error means?  It happens in my urban_networks mod, but I cannot track if its a schematics loading issue, a node metadata issue, or something else entirely.  The error message is:  "WARNING[Server]: Map::getNodeMetadata(): Block not found"
15:49 Helenah I'm desperate to play on the LinuxForks server but I can't find who owwns it. It's in the public listing and I should be able to register an account on it, I'd attempteed registration of 10 different usernames, all report "Username taken" which isn't true, they can't be taken.
15:49 Guest73 When a mapblock is generating, I get this message flooding the log, the map block generates and loads, and then on to the next on_gen call.
15:51 Guest73 Helenah, try finding the forum topic for that server, and post a message there.  You might also find more general info to help you.
15:51 Warr1024 joined #minetest
15:54 Warr1024 joined #minetest
15:55 Helenah "What's the number in the nickname of the original creator of Minetest, minus 1?", ask me a question I can find the answer to, no?
15:56 Helenah So celeron55 but yeah here's the problem with this question...
15:57 Helenah If someone else hadn't told someone who was confused about this like I am, I wouldn't have known...
15:58 Guest73 Questions like these are meant to deny bots and spammers from flooding the server.  For new users, this can be confusing.  Which is why I pointed you to the forum post for that server.
15:59 Helenah Yes and a human needs to be able to answer them at the same time... While I was able to get the creator's name, it took being told to get his nickname. One should be able to "Google around" for the answer.
16:00 FreeFull joined #minetest
16:02 Helenah Done, contacted. :3
16:02 debiankaios joined #minetest
16:03 mrkubax10 joined #minetest
16:08 * Helenah sighs
16:08 Helenah The server is still lying to me...
16:18 MTDiscord <PrairieWind> The Isle of Sodor, lol, looks like someone else watches Thomas
16:18 Guest73 Some server use tools with very "inside" info.  This ensures that users are not noobs, have been in the community awhile, and are more likely  respected and or respectable.
16:19 Guest73 Yes, First map seed I used with Advtrains.  On v6, but I also like v7 for this seed.  My son loved Thomas, and well, I came to love those trains too!!  RIP W Aubrey.
16:30 proller joined #minetest
16:30 Blockhead256[m] Helenah: There's a default password that you don't know. Make a post in the forum topic and hope someone check it, erstazi might. I would but I'm about to go to bed sorry :(
16:48 RhineDevil^ Guest73: Trying Fermat rn, I'll keep you update
16:50 RhineDevil^ What does Fermat do anyway
16:54 Guest73 What do you mean?  If you type in Fermat for the seed, MT converts that to a numeric seed.  I find words easier to remember than 20 digit numbers. :)   Also, I usually use the world name as the seed, for organization at the least.
16:54 RhineDevil^ First try, wasn't nice as expected
16:56 RhineDevil^ Guest73: doubt, used Fermat two times and the seeds are different
16:57 grouinos joined #minetest
17:01 Guest73 With this seed, origin is in the ocean, and you spawn to the south in desert or north into coniferous, or vice versa.  Could also be east west, it's been awhile.  The continent wraps around one side, while the other side appears to be open ocean.  I've explored most of 2km from origin in each direction.    This is probably best of Valleys,
17:01 Guest73 but you could try v7, no rivers, mountains.  Noise values for base terrain in v7 is awfully smooth.  Try these noise params for v7:  np_alt = {offset = -4, scale = 25, spread = {x = 600, y = 600, z = 600}, seed = 5934, octaves = 6, persist = 0.6, lacunarity = 2.05,}
17:01 Guest73 np_base = {offset = -4, scale = 70, spread = {x = 600, y = 600, z = 600}, seed = 5934, octaves = 6, persist = 0.6, lacunarity = 2.05,}
17:01 Guest73 np_height = {offset = -0.5, scale = 1, spread = {x = 500, y = 500, z = 500}, seed = 4213, octaves = 6, persist = 0.7, lacunarity = 2.05,}
17:02 Guest73 Again, no rivers, no mountains with those params.  The np_height noise changes those ugly v7 "mountains" from tall  skinny sticks, to actual hills and mountains, when combined with the other two noise param changes
17:04 RhineDevil joined #minetest
17:04 Guest73 Using Fermat will give the same seed per mapgen, but will give different numeric seed with diff mapgens.  v7 gives one number, valleys another, carpathian another.  But will always provide same number for given mapgen.
17:10 Guest73 My bad, the above is incorrect.  Across Linux and Windows installations, dating back to MT v0.4.14, the same numeric value is generated across all mapgens for a give text value as the seed.  In this case, Fermat has always generated 14971822871466973040 as the numeric seed.  It is case sensitive, so if you type fermat, you will get a different
17:10 Guest73 value.  The text string seed "TheIsleOfSodor" has generated a numeric value of 4866059420164947791 since I began playing MT, on both Windows and Linux installs, multiple MT versions, and all mapgens, including singlenode Lua.
17:13 Guest73 Disclaimer, I quit using the built in mapgens long ago.  I do much prefer my mg_earth mapgen mod, which provides lua implementations of v6,v7, carpathian, valleys, a 3d mapgen, and several others, as well as the ability to "stack" mapgens.  I've stacked the above v7 generated world on top of Carpathian for some interesting results.
17:15 Guest73 If you look at the init.lua for mg_earth, at the top in the settings, you'll find a commented list of mapgen seeds, text string and numeric value, for a number of worlds that I use for testing.
17:17 MTDiscord <luatic> I wonder how you kept mg_earth perf manageable
17:20 Guest73 luatic, what do you mean?
17:25 MTDiscord <luatic> well, how long does generating a chunk take?
17:25 MTDiscord <luatic> from my experience Lua mapgens are pretty slow unless what they do is more or less trivial
17:31 RhineDevil Guest73: where's mg_earth in the game files?
17:33 RhineDevil Btw if possible I'd prefer seeds working on native mapgens like v3 or v7
17:33 RhineDevil *v5
17:34 Guest73 so yes.  they can be.  most existing ones are.  I find that many lua mapgens use the 3d flat map, which in my opinion is a memory hog, and due to the size, a perf hit.  I instead use the buffer object which provides a 2d matrix, smaller and faster in my experience.  paramats mapgens were beasts in this regard, versus GaeldeSaillys valleys
17:34 Guest73 mapgen.
17:37 Guest73 RhineDevil, those seeds work on ALL mapgens.  The text strings are converted to the same numeric value.  I know they provide the same terrain, by comparing the terrain in the built in mapgen to the equivalent mapgen in my mg_earth mod.  Try them.  Explore.  There are litterally 10^20 possibilities.  There is no perfect seed.  It is random
17:37 Guest73 noise.
17:39 RhineDevil Guest73: by work I mean give me the expected result
17:40 Guest73 It is this randomness, and the inability to really control much, that motivated me to start mapgen coding.  I can control many aspects of the terrain in mg_earth, and use noise not as the main factor, but simply as a way to add back randomness to a terrain that is control by distance to points, voronoi cells.
17:40 RhineDevil Would be awesome a mod or something that helps you search/generate a seed with the desired charateristics
17:41 RhineDevil Guest73: so are you the author of mg_earth?
17:43 mrkubax10 joined #minetest
17:45 Guest73 RhineDevil, as stated, seeds are random.  Without exploring and documenting each and every seed, there is no simple answer.  With so many possibilities, the only way to ever know what a seed will produce is for us to start document seeds.   Also, as a side note, if you use only the default MTG game, with no mods, you will get very generic
17:45 Guest73 biomes.  Add naturalbiomes, ebiomes, ethereal and see if the seed looks different.  Just because the map produced sweeping desert with default MTG only, doesn't mean that this will be desert with other mods loaded.  Many biome mods also use a very limit range to define so many biomes, and thus a biome from a given mod could be "overwritten" by a
17:45 RhineDevil Ah yeah you are
17:45 Guest73 mod that defines a new biome using similar heat humidity values.
17:46 RhineDevil Guest73: I use mineclone2
17:46 RhineDevil Anyway
17:46 Guest73 Yes, I am ShadMOrdre.  lurking here through webchat IRC.
17:46 RhineDevil What I desire as I said is a seed with a mountain and yadda yadda
17:47 RhineDevil I find the idea of lua mapgen intriguing
17:47 RhineDevil BUT I fear that always invoking lua for generating terrain will be problematic resource-wise
17:48 RhineDevil By that I mean it might be too much resource-hungry I fear?
17:49 RhineDevil So Guest73 what could you suggest given my situation
17:49 Guest73 So once lua mapgen generates the map, it is no longer used.  With latest release and graphics improvements, once I've generated an area, the lua mapgen is no longer relavant.  The world is generated.  I can fly as fast, lag free, with bloom and unlimited distance.
17:49 RhineDevil Very cool
17:50 RhineDevil What could I do for achieving the location I desire then
17:50 MTDiscord <Warr1024> The slowness of lua mapgens has been talked up quite a bit, but it doesn't actually have to be all that bad (there are optimizations that are not prohibitively difficult) and unless a major part of gameplay is constantly exploring new map areas at a rapid pace, even slow mapgen doesn't have to kill gameplay.
17:51 RhineDevil Since well I have no idea if your mapgen already has stuff helping in that
17:51 RhineDevil And how to toggle them
17:52 Guest73 When flying through any world, imaging that you are a marker on a piece of paper, but in 3d.  you generated the sphere around you and a cone in the direction you are viewing.  You're world is generated in that very limited linear way, pen on paper, drawing a line within the 3d space.  I use a chat command in mg_earth to pregenerate an area, keep
17:52 Guest73 draw distance low, while using unlimited view range.  Draw dist = 20m, unlimited view = 'r'.
17:54 RhineDevil How do I install and use this mod in mapgen?
17:55 RhineDevil Like in which folder should I place it? Just mods?
17:55 Guest73 I am Thanos, destroyer of worlds.  Mapgen coding requires constant world gen, explore, look for defects.  yaddayadda...  I am not patient enough to wait 4 seconds for a block to generate.  So far, mg_earth can run as fast as 300ms, depending on settings, to a crawl of about 3000-4000ms.  Some settings might be faster, but again, once the world
17:55 Guest73 is generated, lua mapgen code, no matter how slow, is not a factor.
17:56 Guest73 I've set my private server to generate 36sqkm  -3000 to 3000 overnight.  When I wake up, I have a pregenerated world to explore, and mapgen code no longer matters.
17:57 Guest73 mg_earth is available on CDB.
17:57 MTDiscord <Warr1024> Having to wait overnight to pregenerate sounds like a more wasteful approach than just on-demand generation 😑
17:57 RhineDevil Seen it, how do I toggle it when generating a world?
17:58 Guest73 setting should be available through the main menu.  all settings should have helpful descriptions.
17:59 Guest73 I would recommend getting the very tailored look you want.  mg_earth, using voronoi for continents, vIslands noise for terrain randomness and cliffs.   These are settings for mg_earth.  Explore...
18:00 RhineDevil How do I select mg_earth options?
18:00 Guest73 Warr1024, mind you that the overnight pregen was for dev.
18:01 Guest73 Current mapgen times for mg_earth posted above.  Best advise is try it or not.  But I doubt you'll be disappointed.  Sometimes, the good stuff takes time......
18:01 RhineDevil Guest73: I got the parameters I don't see where should I input them in minetest
18:01 RhineDevil Both on the headless server and on the GUI client
18:01 Guest73 Still, depending on your device, you should be able to walk around mg_earth and get good results.  If you fly, go fast, or otherwise outrun the mapgen, then you get lag...
18:02 RhineDevil Cause well I'm using the GUI client for testing
18:04 Guest73 ok, so bugs found.
18:05 Guest73 Warr1024, perhaps you can help.  Modpacks are not expandable in the menu, and mod settings do not appear to be available at all, only game settings??
18:06 Guest73 mods in modpacks.. cannot see settings.  i had to move mod out of modpack for mod settings to be visible in main menu.
18:07 Guest73 RhineDevil, you should be able to go to the settings tab, under Content: Mods menu, and see settings options for mg_earth.
18:09 RhineDevil kk, I'm trying to toy around with the settings, I'll try that later
18:09 Guest73 RhineDevil, the client main menu will not show settings for mods loaded in server instance, if they are seperate installations.
18:10 MTDiscord <Warr1024> tbh my knowledge of the main menu is pretty spotty ... I almost never use it.
18:10 Guest73 RhineDevil, a simple, and interesting mapgen is the 3d mapgen, with Terraria as the seed
18:11 Guest73 same here.   I just change the setting in code.
18:15 RhineDevil <Guest73> draw distance low, while using unlimited view range.  Draw dist = 20m, unlimited view = 'r'.
18:15 RhineDevil I can't find these settings in mapgen settings
18:17 Guest73 draw distance is set in game, using + and -.  unlimited view is also ingame, by pressing the 'r' key, you "turn off" draw distance and fog.
18:17 RhineDevil Like I mean, Settings -> All the settings -> Content: mods -> mg_earth
18:18 RhineDevil But I don't find the keys you mentioned
18:18 Guest73 Those are not necessary, and probably undesirable if you have not pregenerated and area.  You should be fine with a draw distance of around 100 to 190, the default, depending on your device.
18:19 Guest73 The keys I mention are not mg_earth settings.  They are in settings, using the hotkeys that you can configure in game, while your are also in world.
18:20 Guest73 They are on the main menu.  Try not to confuse the use of the word settings to always mean mod settings. And I'll try to be far more clear...  :)
18:20 MTDiscord <Warr1024> Starting in 5.7 IIRC there is no default binding for "unlimited viewing range", now players may have to bind that themselves.
18:21 Guest73 the + and - keys and the 'r' key are built in hotkeys that you can configure using the "ESC" menu when in world.
18:21 RhineDevil Guest73: dude please just tell me where should I go once I open the minetest client
18:21 RhineDevil Main menu where??
18:22 RhineDevil There are at least 5 sections of the main meny
18:26 Guest73 Thanks, Warr1024, I forget the details sometimes.  But the hotkey menu is the place to correct my short memory.  I think I need to upgrade from DDR2....  :)
18:27 Guest73 RhineDevil, for setting up the mapgen mod, mg_earth, the settings are on the settings tab.  Click the All Settings button to get to the settings menu.  Go to Content: Mods and you should see mg_earth settings.
18:28 MTDiscord <Warr1024> Well, the "no default binding" thing is new, so if you tell users "hit the R key" and they say it doesn't do anything, that's where the confusion comes from.
18:28 MTDiscord <Warr1024> For people like me who tend to rebind the majority of my keys anyway, it's easy to lose track of what the default bindings ever were in the first place.  I tend to tell people to just check their bindings anyway, even if they haven't customized them.
18:29 RhineDevil Guest73: I see them but the stuff you said isn't mentioned
18:29 MTDiscord <Warr1024> It's not like it's the first time the default bindings have changed either; moving camera perspective from F7 -> C is still pretty fresh in my own memory.
18:29 Guest73 For the + - draw distance keys, they are hotkeys that you can change.  When you in the world, press Escape to bring up the Change Hotkeys button, where you can set the unlimited draw distance key, I use r hence my recommendation.  Warr1024 pointed out that that key is NOT set by default, so r will do nothing if you don't set that key.
18:29 RhineDevil mg_earth.settings.mg_base_eight
18:30 RhineDevil That's an example of setting format
18:37 appguru joined #minetest
18:37 Guest73 RhineDevil, I would recommend setting the following.  enable_vEarth_Simple, enable_vIslands.  You could alternatively set enable_v3D.   The first two settings will enable voronoi continents with modified v7 noise.  Oceans and well, go explore.   The second, the 3d one, enables a fully 3d terrain generation, not with caves, but with sweeping
18:37 Guest73 3D land forms.  Truly worth it.  Better than v5, IMHO, and is essentially paramats original LVM_Example mod.
18:43 Guest73 RhineDevil, for screenshot examples of some of these, look to this thread on the forum,  https://forum.minetest.net/viewtopic.php?f=3&amp;t=156&amp;start=10875.  All screenshots from me are usually some form of this very mapgen, in various configurations.  The 3D mapgen is shown in last May's blog post, the image with Apercys Steampunk Blimp.
19:02 grouinos joined #minetest
19:25 dogbold joined #minetest
19:32 illwieckz joined #minetest
19:39 Guest73 left #minetest
19:42 proller joined #minetest
20:21 AFCM joined #minetest
20:33 RhineDevil Guest73: I don't find in these settings Draw dist = 20m, unlimited view = 'r' though where do I find them?
20:34 RhineDevil Oh he's offline
20:34 RhineDevil Where do I find him?
20:37 Krock RhineDevil: https://github.com/minetest/minetest/blob/master/minetest.conf.example#L3326
20:37 Krock the default key was removed in a recent Minetest version
20:38 Krock + and - keys for changing the draw distance
20:38 jordan4ibanez[m] Yes, and the full range key needs to be bound if you want to admire a mega creation
20:39 RhineDevil Krock: isn't it a visualization setting instead of a mapgen setting?
20:45 muurkha I hit `r` pretty often by accident when I mean to hit `e`
20:46 muurkha which is usually the least convenient possible time for my fps to drop from 30 to 5
20:48 Krock RhineDevil: you asked for draw distance and unlimited view, and that's it.
20:50 duds` joined #minetest
20:55 RhineDevil Krock: I'm asking, I don't have even an idea of what they do
21:00 RhineDevil Like what I wanna know is if they impact mapgen or stuff
21:01 RhineDevil I just know the dude told me to enable them??
21:01 muurkha not mapgen, no
21:01 muurkha but they do impact what you can see of the map
21:05 sagax joined #minetest
21:06 Trifton joined #minetest
21:07 RhineDevil muurkha: ah ok got it
21:14 muurkha if you have a 600-meter-tall tower but your viewing range is limited to 190 m, you aren't going to be able to see the top two thirds of the tower from its base
21:14 muurkha and never more than 380 m
21:44 Talkless joined #minetest
21:58 RhineDevil Just found a ???? in mg_earth. It mentions the "default" mod but I don't see a default mod?
21:58 RhineDevil Also it imports from this default mod some processing stuff?
22:28 RhineDevil Is there a way in mods for printing out values from minetest instance?
22:31 panwolfram joined #minetest
22:37 illwieckz joined #minetest
22:55 MTDiscord <RisingLeaf> what values?
22:55 MTDiscord <RisingLeaf> the default mod is integrated in minetest-game
23:30 Guest17 joined #minetest
23:32 Guest17 ShadMOrdre here again.  Lurking anonymously in webchat.
23:39 RhineDevil Guest17: I've noticed issues with your mod, mostly not being compatible with mineclone
23:39 RhineDevil I'm adding code fixing that
23:40 RhineDevil In particular I'm adding switches that if necessary substitute stuff using "default" from minetest with mcl_core
23:41 RhineDevil By the way your mod is really slow at generating stuff
23:41 RhineDevil If possible I'd like to know how do you pregenerate worlds
23:43 muurkha I think most minetestgame mods aren't compatible with mineclone
23:43 muurkha can you even make a mod that's compatible with both?  I'm not sure
23:43 RhineDevil muurkha: well that's true
23:44 RhineDevil muurkha: yeah it's pretty simple, just use ifs
23:44 muurkha I mean when you upload to the cdb you have to statically declare your dependencies
23:44 muurkha my wife ported a bunch of MTG mods to mineclone2 the other day but hasn't uploaded them anywhere
23:44 muurkha she didn't like mc2 the way it was
23:45 RhineDevil You can declare both default and mcl_core as deps
23:45 RhineDevil What didn't she like?
23:47 muurkha if you declare them both, won't you get errors trying to add them to either game?
23:48 RhineDevil Mhh interesting, default:meselamp is basically equivalent to mcl_ocean:sea_lantern
23:48 RhineDevil muurkha: uuuuuh, no? mcl and minetest use different namespaces
23:51 muurkha she added trashcan, illumination, and bones without modifying them
23:51 muurkha oh, apparently I misunderstood, there were others she tried but failed
23:52 AliasAlreadyTake joined #minetest
23:52 muurkha and then she had written a mod for mese armor in MTG, but of course there is no mese in mcl
23:52 muurkha so she changed it to be "Red Messi Armor" using redstone
23:58 RhineDevil Doesn't look like content existing in minecraft
23:59 Guest17 Sorry, got distracted.  It is easily possible to make mapgen mod compat with any game as long as the game or a mod defines the three basic mapgen aliases, stone water river water.  The mapgen mod must then depend on the one mod providing those aliases.  I MCL auth for this, but never heard back
23:59 muurkha well, like I said, she hasn't uploaded it anywhere

| Channels | #minetest index | Today | | Google Search | Plaintext