Time  Nick             Message
10:32 MTDiscord        <08a​ppguru> Andrey01: Take a look at the grappling hook force fields of https://content.minetest.net/packages/LMD/adv_weapons/
12:45 bobbertson       sfan5, I just want to say thank you for adding https://github.com/minetest/minetest/commit/2424dfe007e451bb02f87884c2b272cf307d6e7c dynamic_add_media it's super helpful for my youtube_queue mod! However, performance surely suffers with transferring media files via this method. My question is, do you think it would be possible and improve performance to instead or have an alternate lua functions that sends some kind of message to all
12:45 bobbertson       the clients that then use an http fetch to get the new media at runtime rather than just on connection?
12:48 sfan5            it'd definitely be possible to have client asynchronously load media and notify the server when they're done
12:49 sfan5            though I wonder if it wouldn't make more sense to wait for CSM to be ready since then everything can happen on the client
12:54 bobbertson       what is CSM exactly?
12:54 sfan5            Lua code the server sends that would run on the client
12:56 bobbertson       ah ok
12:56 bobbertson       my needs is i want to send ogg files to the clients in some form or another
12:56 bobbertson       that are only known while people are on the server
13:17 bobbertson       sfan5, will CSM allow me to have clients run the same httpfetch api thing that the server has access to?
13:17 bobbertson       if so for sure i'll just wait
13:18 sfan5            that way I'm thinking the server invoke the media transfer via the usual ways (HTTP included) and the CSM code gets a notification once it's done
13:38 sfan5            also it's not clear how exactly CSM is going to work so you probably don't want to wait for it
13:41 specing          sfan5: isn't there already a dynamic download call?
13:41 specing          I don't think giving CSMs the ability to fetch from random websites is ok
13:42 sfan5            true, and I wasn't suggesting that
13:45 bobbertson       Ya I don't think that CSM will allow me to do what i want really
13:46 bobbertson       Might have to make the change myself if I want it in there
13:46 bobbertson       specing, are you referring to dynamic_add_media or something else?
13:47 specing          bobbertson: no idea what it's called
13:50 specing          bobbertson: What is this youtube_queue mod?
13:50 specing          sounds a bit illegal
14:02 bobbertson       meh kinda
14:02 bobbertson       im just using it for my private server
14:03 bobbertson       lets users queue search terms to youtube and then youtube-dl downloads the video, extracts it to just an ogg file then pushes it out to everyone to listen to in sync
14:03 bobbertson       it's not really illegal inherently
14:56 specing          bobbertson: well, do you have distribution rights to the audio?
14:57 specing          if not, you are violating copyright
15:10 kb1000           i dont think it being a private server matters much there
15:11 MTDiscord        <05e​xe_virus> Technically it would be okay if you only streamed it
15:11 MTDiscord        <05e​xe_virus> I.e. once per search
15:12 MTDiscord        <05e​xe_virus> Of course that probably violates YouTube's license in some way, though it does help with the copyright issues
15:14 specing          no, you still have no distribution rights
15:15 specing          the only legal way would be to open a small youtube window in minetest with all the ads and annoying bits
15:16 specing          what you can legally do is find music in public domain and stream that
15:16 specing          also some jurisdictions don't recognise public domain, so...
15:17 specing          writing the mod is the easy part
16:17 Sires            Hello could someone help me creating a server with ipv6? do I just check "ipv6_server" and "enable_ipv6"?
16:18 heavygale        yes
16:18 Sires            hmm
16:18 heavygale        not? :D
16:18 Sires            I tried it and my friend couldn't connect
16:18 Sires            ?
16:19 heavygale        how did he try to connect
16:19 Sires            he just put my ipv6 in the ip field, port in port field, his name in name field, password in password field and hit connect
16:20 heavygale        should work
16:20 Sires            weird
16:20 Sires            it just timed out for him
16:21 Sires            could you try connecting to my server just to test?
16:21 heavygale        sure
16:21 heavygale        maybe a firewall issue ?
16:21 Sires            one sec
16:21 Sires            2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd
16:21 Sires            port 30000
16:21 Sires            not sure
16:23 heavygale        times out for me too
16:23 Sires            weird
16:23 heavygale        do you run the server locally on your home comuter?
16:23 Sires            yes
16:24 heavygale        did you open the firewall in your router for 30000 and this address?
16:24 Sires            uuh didn't know I had to do this
16:25 heavygale        i guess so
16:25 Sires            Tho I tested a simple chat room(made in python) with the same person and it worked
16:25 Sires            it was in port 1234
16:25 heavygale        hmm
16:25 Sires            perhaps if I try changing to 1234 it might work?
16:25 heavygale        :D try
16:25 Sires            k one sec
16:26 heavygale        or try to connect to your server with a second client locally, to check if it listens on v6
16:26 Sires            it did work locally
16:26 Sires            before
16:26 Sires            ok I reopened in port 1234
16:26 heavygale        no change for me ^^
16:27 Sires            meh
16:28 Sires            hmm
16:28 Sires            I'm opening it with the "host server" option
16:29 Sires            perhaps if I do a dedicated server it might work?
16:29 heavygale        if you can with a diffrent client locally it should beall fine
16:29 specing          Ah, the long lost art of port forwarding
16:30 Sires            I read I was not supposed to have to port forward when using ipv6
16:30 specing          indeed
16:30 Sires            and I can't port forward in ipv4 because of my ISP
16:30 specing          but NATing is good for security anyway
16:30 heavygale        it'sno forwarding as there's no nat in v6, but opening a firewall is mostly still requiered
16:30 specing          another layer of filtering out bad stuff
16:33 heavygale        sure and always use a vpn, rigt? Oo
16:34 Sires            ok so I'm at "NAT -- Virtual Servers Setup" in my router
16:35 Sires            port 30000 open
16:35 Sires            is that where I should do it?
16:36 Sires            also I opened the server by the terminal if anyone wanna test
16:37 specing          heavygale: a normal VPN only helps if you ISP is malicious
16:37 specing          heavygale: really helpful are multihop VPNs (a la tor)
16:37 heavygale        what for? there's https :)
16:38 specing          heavygale: hiding metadata
16:38 Sires            https://imgur.com/TAlkfFG
16:38 heavygale        looks like v4 only
16:38 Sires            am I doing this right?
16:39 heavygale        (as there' s no nat for v6 ^^)
16:39 Sires            mm
16:39 specing          there is nat for v6
16:39 Sires            heavygale told me to open port in firewall or smth so what am I supposed to do?
16:40 heavygale        in home routers?
16:40 big_caballito[m] you need to allow incoming traffic on port 30000 or whatever
16:41 Sires            what I showed in my screenshot isn't doing that?
16:41 heavygale        your screenshot only states v4 addresses
16:41 Sires            ooh I think I found smth
16:41 Sires            one sec
16:42 Sires            here: https://imgur.com/o3LXuCs
16:42 Sires            does that look what I need to use?
16:44 Sires            welp gonna try it anyways
16:44 heavygale        what router is that
16:46 Sires            model?
16:46 heavygale        or compand? ^^
16:46 sfan5            by the way MinetestBot can test reachability for you
16:46 sfan5            !up 2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd
16:46 MinetestBot      [2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd]:30000 seems to be down
16:47 Sires            humax hgb10r-02 I think
16:47 Sires            the server is at port 1234
16:47 sfan5            !up 2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd 1234
16:47 MinetestBot      [2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd]:1234 seems to be down
16:48 sfan5            how does your minetest.conf look like?
16:48 Sires            pretty default I think, except for ipv6 stuff enable
16:48 Sires            enabled*
16:48 Sires            you want to see the entire thing?
16:48 sfan5            yeah just to make sure
16:48 Sires            k
16:48 Sires            one sec
16:49 big_caballito[m] I think it's probably a firewall issue
16:50 Sires            https://termbin.com/vupa
16:51 sfan5            yeah that looks correct
16:51 sfan5            are you running the server from the menu or commandline?
16:52 big_caballito[m] is port 1234 forwarded?
16:52 Sires            I tried both
16:52 Sires            1234 I think not
16:52 heavygale        https://www.net.com.br/documento/2018/09/12/user-manual-for-hgb10r-02-1374091901758.pdf can't find any firewall stuff,..only for blocking, not fire whitelisting?
16:52 Sires            but 30000 didn't work either
16:52 Sires            I just did 1234 because it worked with other application
16:53 big_caballito[m] you have to forward port 1234 then allow traffic for that port in your firewall
16:54 sfan5            did it work over ipv4? did that other application use TCP? do you perhaps have a local firewall?
16:54 Sires            but I tried forwarding port 30000 and didn't work
16:54 Sires            Over ipv4 I can't do port forwarding anymore, changed router and it won't allow me to
16:54 sfan5            and if you're running linux, please check using netstat -uln that minetest is listening
16:54 big_caballito[m] port forwarding is on your router, firewall is on you PC
16:54 Sires            but I could do with ipv4 before changing router
16:55 Sires            sfan5: it lists "udp6       0      0 :::1234                 :::* "
16:55 Sires            I guess thats minetest
16:55 sfan5            should be, yeah
16:56 Sires            lemme check firewall
16:56 Sires            k I just stopped firewall
16:56 sfan5            !up 2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd 1234
16:56 MinetestBot      [2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd]:1234 seems to be down
16:56 Sires            I'll put the server at port 30000
16:57 Sires            I just turned it off
16:57 Sires            k its on now
16:57 Sires            !up 2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd
16:57 MinetestBot      [2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd]:30000 seems to be down
16:57 Sires            asdfasdfas
16:58 sfan5            hm
16:58 Sires            disabled ipv6 firewall on router
16:59 Fractalis        You need to find a way to port forward, all routers have a way to get in.
16:59 Sires            do I have to restart router for it to work?
16:59 sfan5            doubt it
16:59 Sires            !up 2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd
16:59 MinetestBot      [2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd]:30000 is up (221ms)
16:59 Sires            AWWWW
16:59 Sires            YUSS
16:59 big_caballito[m] ysy!!!!
16:59 Sires            anyone wanna join
16:59 Fractalis        nice :)
16:59 MTDiscord        <10J​ordach> conglaturations
16:59 Sires            I bugged minetest_game by putting animation_blend at 1 sec
17:00 Sires            and watter has negative viscosity I think
17:00 Sires            thanks all for the help
17:00 big_caballito[m] whats special about your server
17:00 big_caballito[m] ie why shoud i join
17:00 Sires            nothing
17:00 Sires            its just if you want
17:00 big_caballito[m] *should
17:01 big_caballito[m] cool
17:13 big_caballito[m] sfan5: do i have to do anything special to connect to ipv6?
17:13 big_caballito[m] server?
17:14 sfan5            ipv6 is enabled by default on the client
17:14 big_caballito[m] !up 2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd
17:14 MinetestBot      [2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd]:30000 seems to be down
17:15 big_caballito[m] oh thats why
17:15 specing          Why does localplayer:get_wield_index return a 0-indexed number? Wouldn't it make more sense to make CSM developer lives easier by making the number be 1-index?
17:15 Sires            wait what
17:15 Sires            we are playing
17:17 big_caballito[m] !up 2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd
17:17 MinetestBot      [2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd]:30000 is up (232ms)
17:17 specing          (I'll put my question to -dev)
17:17 Sires            !up 2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd
17:17 MinetestBot      [2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd]:30000 is up (221ms)
17:17 Sires            just checking*
17:20 big_caballito[m] connection keeps timing out for me :/
17:21 big_caballito[m] no i was just typing it wrong
17:26 Sires            *closed it
17:35 bobbertson       specing, you are right that it's not legal to let people use it for that
17:35 bobbertson       but i mean there's nothing illegal about the mod itself lol
17:36 bobbertson       just like when you get a torrent client there's nothing illegal about it
18:41 Sires            !up 2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd
18:41 MinetestBot      [2804:14d:880:9568:1012:45ee:249b:cbbd]:30000 is up (219ms)
18:47 Krock            assuming MTB lives in Europe, your server is like in Chile or Australia
18:47 Krock            or just super bad relay stations
19:16 tango_           or it's using PTTH instead of FTTH
19:16 tango_           (P for Pigeons)
19:18 Follpvosten[m]   You mean IPoAC?
19:21 tango_           Follpvosten[m]: well, the physical side of it, yes
19:21 tango_           I just found this out on wikipedia:
19:21 tango_           In September 2009, a South African IT company based in Durban pitted an 11-month-old bird armed with a data packed 4 GB memory stick against the ADSL service from the country's biggest Internet service provider, Telkom. The pigeon, Winston, took an hour and eight minutes to carry the data 80 km (50 miles). In all, the data transfer took two hours, six minutes, and fifty-seven seconds—the same amount of
19:21 tango_           time it took to transfer 4% of the data over the ADSL
19:22 tango_           the problem with IPoAC is the latency, but since we're seeing numbers in the 200s of ms, it might just as well be that
19:23 Follpvosten[m]   Makes sense lol
19:23 Krock            data thoughput is insane
19:41 tango_           quoting good ol' Tanenbaum, «Never underestimate the bandwidth of a station wagon full of tapes hurtling down the highway.»
20:08 Krock            Tannenbaum? a pinetree?
20:17 tango_           single n
20:32 jonadab          It's spelled "Tanenbaum", but it's pronounced "minix".
20:33 jonadab          HTH.HAND.
21:21 Andrey01         appguru: your mod doesn`t work, it throws out to me "attempt to index global 'adv_weapons' (a nil value)"
21:23 Andrey01         I can not see how you made the grappling hook :(
21:38 bobbertson       hey sfan5 do you think it would be worth making a Client::handleCommand_MediaFetch type ordeal where dynamic_add_media has an optional second arg that is a bool as to whether to use a remote_media server to fetch from using an m_media_downloader or such? Or am I going down a rabbit hole that doesn't make sense?
21:39 bobbertson       Asking you since you implemented the thing closest to what I think would be useful for transferring music files at runtime
21:39 bobbertson       or sound files
21:40 sfan5            how would the server know when the sound file is available for playback in that case?
21:41 sfan5            also here's an easy optimization you can make specifically for your case since you're already editing the code: in Server::dynamicAddMedia() only send the packet over channel 0
21:41 bobbertson       i was thinking that handleCommand_MediaFetch would end with some sort of callback to the server saying it's done, but ya that is the biggest head scratch for me
21:42 bobbertson       :o will that half the amount of data sent?
21:43 bobbertson       ok ya i will make that optimization for my server
21:43 bobbertson       but still think it would be nice to have the ability for getting clients to fetch from remote_media server
21:44 sfan5            yes that'll halve it
22:22 niwla23[m]       Would it be technically possible to make sth like bungeecord for minetest?
22:26 Fractalis        AFAIK Strings and lines are still a issue with minetest engine,
22:28 Fractalis        It would be a better question for #minetest-dev i think
22:28 MTDiscord        <10J​ordach> meanwhile i've been writing a lua transpiler that takes the pain away
22:34 TableToo         hello
22:34 TableToo         minetesters
22:35 Fractalis        Hi minetester LOL
23:58 rubenwardy       niwla23[m]: theoretically yes